baseedge_labs
← research

How far does price actually run once it leaves VWAP, and does a fixed-point target survive a re-rating index?

Aug 24, 2026 · BaseEdge Labs research

Cross-Strategy

The question started with one trade: a short on Asia hit its full stop-loss despite pushing 45+ points favorable at one point. That led to two separate questions worth answering with real data rather than a gut read.

This post reports findings only: what we tested, how, and what we concluded. The underlying figures are not published.

What we found

  1. NY expands furthest once price leaves VWAP. It cleared a 25-point move most of the time. Asia was the weakest of the three sessions; London sat between.
  2. Shorts ran further than longs in every session.
  3. Fixed-point targets drift as the index re-rates. Expansion measured in points climbed steadily across the sample. Measured as a percentage of price it stayed roughly flat. Measured in ATR multiples it was the most stable of the three units.
  4. A fixed 30-point target got much easier to hit from 2024 to 2026, mostly because the index got bigger. The setup itself did not improve. The %-of-price and ATR readings of the same trades barely moved.
  5. Still unmeasured: how far a trade moves against you before the favorable move shows up.

How far does price run once it starts expanding away from VWAP?

Method. Using 1-minute MNQ data, we flagged an “expansion start” event per session (Asia, London, NY). It fires when price is on one side of session VWAP and VWAP’s own slope clears a minimum-points threshold over a lookback window. The event is the first bar a debounced version of that condition turns true, not a strict crossover. From each event, entry was queued at the next bar’s open, matching this project’s fill convention. We then measured the maximum favorable excursion (MFE) over a 45-minute cap, and how often it reached 25, 30 and 35 points.

Findings.

The gap in this table on its own: nothing here measures how much the trade has to survive against it before the favorable move shows up. A session with a great hit rate and a routine 20-point drawdown first is not tradeable with a tight stop. That is the natural next study, not yet run.

Does a fixed-point target even mean the same thing across the sample?

The Nasdaq-100 re-rated sharply higher over the 2024-2026 window used here. We re-ran the same expansion study broken out by quarter. Each event was recorded in three parallel units: raw points, % of entry price, and multiples of a 14-period ATR. That shows why the re-rating matters for anyone sizing TP/SL in fixed points.

Findings.

A fixed 30-point target looked far easier to clear in 2026 than in 2024. That is mostly the index getting bigger under a static number, not the setup improving. The %-of-price and ATR-normalized readings of the identical trades barely moved over the same period.

What this doesn’t answer yet

This is one instrument over one 2.5-year window. It says %- and ATR-normalized sizing is more stationary than fixed points here. It does not say the coefficient holds indefinitely, or whether the finding generalizes to other index futures (ES, YM) with different long-run price appreciation. A research brief on exactly that, using longer, cross-instrument history on whether volatility scales with price level structurally or moves on its own regime cycle, is out for external research; results pending.