Test window: CME Micro Nasdaq-100 futures, January 2024 through August 21, 2026, every 18:00 ET Globex open in that span. Results are hypothetical backtests over that period and include commission and one tick of slippage per side.
What we found
- The v1.5.0 baseline lost money on every day of the week. Every leg had a profit factor below 1. Monday was the worst by a wide margin.
- Stop-and-Reverse turned it net positive. Every SAR variant in a 2,592-combination grid was net positive over the same history the baseline lost on.
- The reversal leg is not a patch. Reversal trades earned about as much as initial trades, close to half the total edge.
- SAR cut drawdown to a small fraction of what the baseline’s losses imply.
- Runner brackets beat scalps. Brackets of 20 points or less barely clear slippage and commission.
- The first 5-minute bar after the open is the strongest signal of direction of the seven we tested, by a clear margin.
- Some plausible signals have no edge, or an inverted one. Where the RTH session closes against VWAP is a coin flip. A close near the lows and a strong late-session push both tend to mean-revert.
- On Monday, “follow the trend” is wrong. A bullish 1-hour EMA stack on Monday was the strongest short signal we found.
The baseline (v1.5.0) lost money
Method. Directional entries at the 18:00 ET Globex open, per day of week, with the shipped brackets:
| Day | Direction | Bracket (TP/SL, points) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sunday | Long only | 120/50 | Net negative, despite a high win rate |
| Monday | Long only | 80/40 | Net negative — the worst leg |
| Tuesday | Both | 60/30 | Net negative |
| Wednesday | Both | 60/30 | Net negative |
| Thursday | Short only | 50/30 | Net negative |
| Full 2.5 years | Baseline defaults | Net negative, profit factor well below 1 |
Findings.
- Monday was the worst leg by a wide margin: a low win rate and the lowest profit factor of the week.
- Sunday won often but still lost money. That is a payoff problem, not a hit-rate problem.
Diagnosis.
- The 18:00 fakeout trap. Thin liquidity right at the Globex open produces frequent small probes. They trigger the wide 30-50 point stops before any real overnight trend sets in.
- No way to capture the reversal. Once stopped out, the baseline sat flat for the rest of the evening, including on nights the market then ran a long way the other way.
The Stop-and-Reverse fix
Instead of taking the full loss and staying flat: enter with a tight 10-15 point initial stop. If that stop is hit, immediately flip into the opposite direction with a wider 60-100 point runner target.
Method. A 2,592-combination grid sweep across the full 2.5-year history. Three bracket styles stood out:
| Bracket style | Initial (TP/SL) | Reversal (TP/SL) | How it ranked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large Runner | 120/10 | 100/10 | Best profit factor, net profit and risk-adjusted return; lowest drawdown of the three |
| Medium Balanced | 60/10 | 60/35 | Top win rate of the three; net profit close behind Large Runner |
| Scalpy | 20/10 | 20/10 | Barely positive |
Findings.
- Every SAR variant tested was net positive. The baseline, with no SAR, was net negative over the same history.
- Reversal trades contributed about as much as initial trades across the top configs. The SAR leg is close to half the strategy’s edge.
- Max drawdown fell to a small fraction of the baseline’s in every SAR variant. The baseline’s drawdown was implied from its net loss and profit factor, not measured directly.
- Scalpy brackets (20 points or less) barely clear fixed costs. Round-trip slippage plus commission eats most of a 20-point edge. Runner brackets (60-100 point targets) dominate.
Why the raw open is such a noisy signal — the microstructure literature
- Opening range price discovery (Biais, Hillion, Spatt 1999; Barclay & Hendershott 2003) — pre-open indicators built on static historical bars have low signal-to-noise because order-book depth doesn’t exist until trading actually starts. Institutional directional commitment shows up in the first opening candle itself, not before it.
- Intraday-to-overnight rebalancing (Lou, Polk, Skouras 2019; Bogousslavsky 2021) — the final 30-60 minutes of the RTH cash session (15:00-16:00 ET) are heavily shaped by Market-on-Close index rebalancing and mechanical ETF hedging flow. When the cash market closes at 16:00, that artificial flow vanishes — strong late-afternoon pushes frequently mean-revert by the time Globex reopens at 18:00.
- Day-of-week seasonality (Birru 2018; French 1980) — institutional order flow shows real calendar regularities from weekend risk absorption and Monday post-close positioning.
Testing 7 signal types against the actual 18:00 open
Method. A head-to-head test of what forecasts direction over the first two hours after the open, across every session in the window.
| Rank | Signal | Condition tested | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | First 5-min opening bar | Green or red 1st bar | Strongest edge tested — direction tends to follow the bar |
| 2 | Day-of-week | Sunday / Monday | Strong calendar bias — Sunday leans bullish, Monday bearish |
| 3 | 3-day macro trend | Return > +1% | Moderate edge, bullish |
| 4 | 1-hour EMA stack (9>21>50) | Bull stack | Modest edge, bullish |
| 5 | RTH close vs. session VWAP | Above / below | No edge — coin flip |
| 6 | RTH close location in range | Close at lows | Inverted — tends to bounce (mean reversion) |
| 7 | Last-hour RTH momentum | Late rally / dump | Inverted — tends to unwind (MOC unwind) |
Findings.
- The first 5-minute opening candle is the strongest signal tested by a clear margin, for both green and red bars. Its effect is far larger than anything else on the list.
- Two signals that sound plausible had no edge or an inverted one. VWAP position at the RTH close is a coin flip. Both “close near the lows” and “strong late-session momentum” tend to mean-revert rather than continue, which fits the MOC-unwind mechanism above.
Combining day-of-week with the EMA stack
| Day | 1H EMA stack | Lean over the next two hours | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sunday | Bull stack | Bullish | Aggressive long |
| Sunday | Bear stack | Bearish, with the heaviest declines in the table | Aggressive short |
| Monday | Bull stack | Bearish — the strongest short signal in the table | Short only — fade the bull trend |
| Monday | Bear stack | Mildly bearish | Short only — continuation |
| Tuesday | Bull stack | Bullish | Long only |
| Thursday | Bull stack | Bullish | Long only |
| Thursday | Bear stack | Bearish | Short only |
Finding. Monday is the clearest case where the naive “follow the trend” read is wrong in both stack states. A bull stack on Monday is the strongest short signal in the table. That fits the baseline’s own Monday leg being its worst performer by far.
Recommended production architecture (hybrid triple filter)
[1. Macro Calendar & Trend Gate]
├─ Sunday: default long bias unless in a heavy 1H bear stack
├─ Monday: default short bias (fade the bull stack specifically)
└─ Tue/Thu: gated by the 1-hour EMA stack (9 > 21 > 50)
│
▼
[2. Opening Price Discovery, 18:00-18:05 ET]
└─ Enter at 18:05 ET only when the 1st 5-min candle confirms the macro bias
│
▼
[3. Asymmetric Stop & Reverse Bracket]
├─ Initial SL: tight 10-15 points
├─ Initial TP: 60-120 points
└─ On stop-out: immediate reverse into a 60-100pt runner target
Design intent, drawn from the backtests above and not a forecast: replace guessing at 18:00:00 sharp with a real signal, and lift directional accuracy from roughly a coin flip toward what the opening-bar test showed. Keep drawdown at the level the SAR runs showed. It is a structural fix, not a parameter tweak on a strategy whose baseline was losing money to begin with.
Caveats
- Every result here is a hypothetical backtest on one instrument over one 2.5-year window, not a prediction of future results.
- The SAR brackets were chosen from a grid run over the full history, and are reported on that same history.